Plagiarism:
Is it Worth It?
Dr. Pam Dennis
Fall Semester, 2006
What is Plagiarism?
nUsing another person’s idea, opinion, or theory without
giving proper credit
nEmploying any
facts, statistics, graphs, drawings that are not common knowledge without giving proper credit
nQuoting another person’s actual spoken or written words
without giving proper credit
nParaphrasing
another person’s spoken or written words without giving proper credit
Consequences?
nRevision of paper for lower grade
nFailing grade
nFailing course
nSuspension
nDegree revocation
nFiring
nLaw suit
nImprisonment (China and South Korea)
However,
nNearly 80% of college students admit they have cheated
n36% of undergraduates admit to plagiarizing
n97.5% of high school students let others copy their work (only 58.3% in 1969)
n54% of students copy from the Internet
www.plagiarism.org/plagiarism_stats.html
Reasons Student Plagiarize
nMisunderstanding of proper citation
nBelief that writing skills are inadequate
nDesire for high grades and competition for jobs
nBelief that everyone else is doing it
nPoor time management and planning skills
nThrill of cheating and not getting caught
Can We Trust Anyone?
“Famous” Plagiarists
nBeatle George Harrison (1971)
nSen. Joseph Biden, Jr., D-Del. – presidential hopeful (1987)
nMike Barnicle – Boston Globe (1998)
nStephen Glass – The New Republic (1998)
nStephen Ambrose and Doris Kearns Goodwin – authors (2002)
nReport by British government related to weapons of mass destruction (2003)
nJayson Blair, New York Times (2003)
nLawrence H. Tribe – Harvard law prof. (2004)
Strategies for Avoiding Plagiarism
nPut in quotations everything that comes directly from the text especially when taking notes.
nParaphrase, but be sure that you are not just rearranging or replacing a few words.
nCheck your paraphrase against the original text to be sure you have not accidentally used the same phrases or words,
and that the information is accurate.
What is Common Knowledge
Facts
that can be found in numerous places and are likely to be known by a lot of people.
Example: John F. Kennedy was elected President of the United States in 1960. No need for citation.
Example: According to a recent biography on John F. Kennedy, he was considered the greatest
President to have ever served (Author __). This is an opinion by the author and
not a fact, so it must be cited
Direct Quote
•Must
include quote marks or be inset and must include a citation
“While course-related library instruction is still widely practiced, librarians are moving
away from talking about information sources as ends in themselves, and towards an information literacy, problem based approach
to information gathering where sources have a secondary role” (Bopp and Smith 13).
OR
While
course-related library instruction is still widely
practiced,
librarians are moving away from talking about
information
sources as ends in themselves, and towards
an
information literacy, problem based approach to
information
gathering where sources have a secondary
role
(Bopp and Smith 13).
Resource
–
Bopp,
Richard E., and Linda C. Smith. Reference and Information
Services:
An Introduction. Englewood, CO: Libraries
Unlimited,
1995.
Unacceptable Paraphrase
Paraphrase
While
course-related library teaching is still commonly practiced, librarians are moving away from speaking about information sources
as ends, and towards . . .
Original
“While course-related library instruction
is still widely practiced, librarians are moving away from talking about information sources as ends in themselves, and towards
an information literacy, problem based approach to information gathering where sources have a secondary role” (Bopp
and Smith 13).
Why Unacceptable
nWriter changed only a few words and phrases or changed the order of the original sentences.
nWriter failed to cite a source for any of the ideas or facts.
Acceptable
Paraphrase
Paraphrase
Though
librarians still use course-related library instruction, there is now a move toward an “information literacy, problem
based approach” with sources assuming a secondary role (Bopp and Smith 13).
Original
“While course-related library instruction is still widely practiced, librarians are moving away from talking
about information sources as ends in themselves, and towards an information literacy, problem based approach to information
gathering where sources have a secondary role” (Bopp and Smith 13).
Why Acceptable
nRecords information in the original accurately.
nGives credit for ideas in the passage.
nIndicates which parts were taken directly from the source by putting the passage in quotation marks and citing the page
number.
Using the World Wide Web
as a Source
The same
rules apply for using information from the Internet in a paper. Text as well
as images copied or paraphrased should include a citation.
MLA
style –
“While
course-related library instruction is still widely practiced, librarians are moving away from talking about information sources
as ends in themselves, and towards an information literacy, problem based approach to information gathering where sources
have a secondary role” (Bopp and Smith 13).
Resource
–
Bopp,
Richard E., and Linda C. Smith. Reference and Information
Services:
An Introduction. Englewood, CO: Libraries Unlimited, 1995.
Turabian/Chicago
style –
“While course-related library instruction is still widely practiced, librarians are moving away
from talking about information sources as ends in themselves, and towards an information literacy, problem based approach
to information gathering where sources have a secondary role.”1
1Richard E. Bopp and Linda C.
Smith, Reference and Information Services: An Introduction (Englewood,
CO: Libraries Unlimited, 1995), 13.
Resource –
Bopp,
Richard E., and Linda C. Smith. Reference and Information
Services: An Introduction. Englewood, CO: Libraries Unlimited, 1995.
APA
style –
“While course-related library instruction is still widely practiced, librarians are moving away
from talking about information sources as ends in themselves, and towards an information literacy, problem based approach
to information gathering where sources have a secondary role” (Bopp and Smith, 1995).
Resource
–
Bopp,
R.E., & Smith, L.C. (1995). Reference and Information Services: An
Introduction. Englewood, CO: Libraries Unlimited.
Resources in the Library
Go to library’s website –
www.lambuth.edu/academics/library/library.html
•Use
Electronic Catalog
•Use
Databases
•Use
Citation Style Sheets
•Use
Finding Aids
Strategies for Avoiding Plagiarism (in review)
nPut in quotations everything that comes directly from the text especially when taking notes.
nParaphrase, but be sure that you are not just rearranging or replacing a few words.
nCheck your paraphrase against the original text to be sure you have not accidentally used the same phrases or words,
and that the information is accurate.
Words of Wisdom
nMake sure you know what citation style to use
nConsult the library’s web page for guidance or ask a librarian
nIf you have a question about your paper, ask your professor to look over it
nStart early on your assignment so you are not tempted to cut corners
nPick a topic about which you can enjoy writing and have fun learning about it